Head Over Heels (2001)

Amanda Pierce (Potter) is living the high life in New York City. She's an art restorer at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and she's even lucked into a luxurious East-side apartment with four gorgeous supermodels as roommates. The only thing missing in her life is a man who will be true to her. But then she meets Jim Winston (Prinze Jr.), a guy who likely won't cheat on her. There's only one problem ­- Jim may be a lady killer, literally. In her hilarious search for the truth, Amanda learns a thing or two about friendship and the whole improbable concept of falling head over heels in love.